Shared Custody in Quebec: Criteria Used by the Courts and Mistakes to Avoid
Shared custody refers to the division of a child's residential time between parents, generally involving at least 40% of the time with each parent. This distinction is particularly relevant when calculating child support. Equal parenting time, introduced through federal legislative reforms, means that both parents spend substantially equivalent amounts of time with their child, without necessarily requiring an exact division of residential time.

What Is Shared Custody in Quebec?
The concept of shared custody is commonly used in Quebec's legal and tax terminology. It primarily describes how a child's residential time is divided between parents, particularly for child support calculations.
Parenting time, a concept established under the federal Divorce Act, focuses more on the exercise of parental responsibilities and the division of time spent with the child, without relying on the numerical thresholds associated with custody arrangements.
In practice, both terms describe essentially the same situation. The main difference lies in the terminology used depending on whether the parents are married and subject to federal divorce law or unmarried and governed by Quebec law.
The Fundamental Criterion: The Best Interests of the Child
In Quebec, the primary consideration is the best interests of the child. Judges examine several factors to determine whether shared custody is appropriate, including stability, emotional security and the child's overall development. Every family situation is unique, and no single factor automatically guarantees that shared custody will be granted.
According to the Government of Quebec and Éducaloi, courts must assess the family's circumstances as a whole before making a custody decision.
The Main Criteria Considered by the Courts
Stability of the Child's Living Environment
Judges pay particular attention to the stability each parent can provide. They consider work schedules, parental availability, the ability to maintain consistent routines and continuity in the child's living environment.
A parent who can provide a stable and predictable environment may have an advantage when seeking shared custody.
The Child's Age and Needs
The child's age, maturity level and specific needs are also taken into consideration. For older children, their preferences may be considered, although they are not necessarily decisive. For younger children, courts carefully assess their ability to adapt to living in two different households.
Geographical Proximity Between Parents' Homes
The distance between the parents' residences is an important factor. Shared custody is generally easier to arrange when both parents live reasonably close to one another. This proximity helps children maintain consistent routines, particularly regarding school attendance, extracurricular activities and social relationships.
Parental Involvement Before and After Separation
A parent's past and current involvement in the child's life plays an important role. Courts examine which parent was responsible for daily care, education and activities before the separation. A parent who has consistently played an active role in raising the child may strengthen their request for shared custody.
The Parents' Ability to Communicate and Cooperate
Shared custody requires a minimum level of communication between parents. Courts assess whether parents can make decisions together, exchange important information and manage disagreements without exposing their child to conflict. A highly contentious relationship may seriously undermine a request for shared custody.
The Absence of Domestic or Family Violence
Courts consider the presence or absence of family violence in accordance with the fundamental principle of the child's best interests, as established under section 33 of the Civil Code of Québec and section 16(3) of the Divorce Act.
Even when a child has not been directly subjected to violence, exposure to violence between parents remains a significant concern. Such circumstances can compromise the safety and stability necessary for a balanced division of parental responsibilities.
Common Mistakes to Avoid When Applying for Shared Custody
Assuming Shared Custody Is an Automatic Right
One common mistake is believing that shared custody is the default arrangement or an automatic entitlement.
In reality, parents must demonstrate, with supporting evidence, that shared custody is the arrangement that best serves their child's interests.
Demonstrating a Lack of Cooperation
Excessively criticizing the other parent, refusing to communicate or repeatedly engaging in conflict can seriously damage your credibility before the court. Judges look for parents who can prioritize their child's needs over personal disagreements.
Involving the Child in Parental Conflicts
Drawing a child into parental disputes, attempting to influence what they say or using them to relay messages between parents is strongly discouraged by the courts. Such behaviour may work against a parent seeking shared custody.
Underestimating the Importance of Legal Guidance
Many parents attempt to handle custody matters independently without fully understanding the legal implications. Poor legal strategies or inadequately prepared proceedings can jeopardize their chances of obtaining a balanced parenting arrangement.
The Importance of Legal Representation
A family lawyer can help you determine whether shared custody is a realistic option in your circumstances, prepare a strong case and avoid mistakes that could negatively affect your parental rights. A well-prepared approach that prioritizes the child's best interests can significantly improve the chances of achieving a favourable outcome.
Shared Custody Begins with a Thoughtful Approach
Shared custody in Quebec is based on several specific criteria and is never automatically granted. Parents seeking this arrangement must demonstrate their ability to provide stability, cooperation and continuity in their child's life.
By avoiding common mistakes and obtaining appropriate legal advice, parents can put themselves in a stronger position to reach an agreement or obtain a court decision that reflects their child's needs.
Contact Grenier Laliberté lawyers in Longueuil for personalized legal advice and dedicated representation focused on protecting your child's best interests and your parental rights.
